My post from Lohti's thread:
Me wrote:
MeaCulpa wrote:
I would think that you should do your own story.
Same. With all the characters, preferably, baseline Human / whatever race it features.
That way teamwork is actually worth the effort, instead of just soloing the mooks like Mr. Smith or some other action flick hero.
Of what you suggested, survival horror. Everyone is also baseline, they have NO special powers, none are military / police trained, none have weapons, etc. Five random schmucks, something they (preferably) CANNOT defeat in a fight, etc.
Fantasy is done too often in general, and the fights are too absurd.
Interaction based RP's can be nice, but often times they involve fighting anyways. Worse, the interactions tend to be so false, it isn't even funny. While Fantasy RP's tend to be a character showing off their combat abilities, these tend to be the showing off of Class, tastes, lifestyle, etc.
Crime... could be interesting. Though the creator would need to have a set outcome, not be involved in the case itself (or manage their posts well), keep the outcome hidden and unexpected, etc. Better yet, purposely mislead. One of the things I was thinking of doing for a fantasy RP was two characters, one a prick but sincere, the other kind but a backstabber. Guess who'd get accused of being the spy, killed, and then revealed at the end to have been loyal?
College... no. I have enough of school as is.